Viability Of Claim For Conversion Of Electronic Data Certified To New York Court

The Second Circuit has asked the highest court of New York state to clarify the law regarding whether a claim of conversion can exist where the property converted consists solely of electronic data.

In Thyroff v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co., 460 F.3d 400 (2d Cir. Aug. 21, 2006), a former insurance agent who leased a computer system from his principal sued for conversion when the insurance company reclaimed the computer. The agent had installed various software of his own on the leased system and created electronic documents with that software, all of which he alleged were converted when the company took the computer.

The district court dismissed conversion claims based on the fact that the company owned the computer, but the Second Circuit disagreed that such ownership interest alone was a barrier to the claim. However, it analyzed New York law concerning the applicability of conversion claims to intangible property and found the matter “unsettled.” It certified the question of whether “a claim for the conversion of electronic data [is] cognizable under New York law.”